Discovering new 3D bioprinting applications: Analyzing the case of optical tissue phantoms

Marisela Rodriguez-Salvador

Article ID: 178
Vol 5, Issue 1, 2019, Pages

VIEWS - 1297 (Abstract) 402 (PDF)


Optical tissue phantoms enable to mimic the optical properties of biological tissues for biomedical device calibration, new equipment validation, and clinical training for the detection, and treatment of diseases. Unfortunately, current methods for their development present some problems, such as a lack of repeatability in their optical properties. Where the use of three-dimensional (3D) printing or 3D bioprinting could address these issues. This paper aims to evaluate the use of this technology in the development of optical tissue phantoms. A competitive technology intelligence methodology was applied by analyzing Scopus, Web of Science, and patents from January 1, 2000, to July 31, 2018. The main trends regarding methods, materials, and uses, as well as predominant countries, institutions, and journals, were determined. The results revealed that, while 3D printing is already employed (in total, 108 scientific papers and 18 patent families were identified), 3D bioprinting is not yet applied for optical tissue phantoms. Nevertheless, it is expected to have significant growth. This research gives biomedical scientists a new window of opportunity for exploring the use of 3D bioprinting in a new area that may support testing of new equipment and development of techniques for the diagnosis and treatment of diseases.

Full Text:



ASTM F2792-10, 2010, Standard Terminology for Additive

Manufacturing Technologies. West Conshohocken, PA:

ASTM International.

Hull, C W, 1984, Apparatus for Production of Three Dimensional Objects by Stereolithography. Patent Number.

US4575330A. UVP Inc.

Ventola C L, 2014, Medical applications for 3D printing:

Current and projected uses. Pharm Ther, 39(10): 704–711.

3D, 2018, What is 3D Printing? Available

from: [Last

accessed on 2018 Nov 14].

Radenkovic D, Solouk A, Seifalian A, 2016, Personalized

development of human organs using 3D printing technology.

Med Hypotheses, 87: 30–33.


Jürgen G, Thomas B, Torsten B, et al., 2016, Biofabrication:

Reappraising the definition of an evolving field.

Biofabrication, 8(1): 13001.


Mandrycky C, Wang Z, Kim K, et al., 2016, 3D bioprinting

for engineering complex tissues. Biotechnol Adv, 34(4): 422–

Huang Y, Zhang X F, Gao G, et al., 2017, 3D bioprinting and

the current applications in tissue engineering. Biotechnol J,

(8): 1600734.

Lee J M, Sing S L, Zhou M, et al., 2018, 3D bioprinting

processes: A perspective on classification and terminology. Int J

Bioprint, 4(2): 1–10.

Ozbolat I T, Peng W, Ozbolat V, 2016, Application areas of

D bioprinting. Drug Disc Today, 21(8): 1257–1271. https://

Rodríguez-Salvador M, Rio-Belver R M, Garechana-

Anacabe G, 2017, Scientometric and patentometric analyses

to determine the knowledge landscape in innovative

technologies: The case of 3D bioprinting. PLoS One, 12(6):


Murphy S V, Atala A, 2014, 3D bioprinting of

tissues and organs. Nat Biotechnol, 32: 773–785.

Wang M, Shen S, Yang J, et al., 2014, 3D Printing Method

For Freeform Fabrication Of Optical Phantoms Simulating

Heterogeneous Biological Tissue. SPIE BiOS, 8945: 8945091-

Zhao S, Gu Y, Xue P, et al., 2010, Imaging port wine stains

by fiber optical coherence tomography. J Biomed Opt, 15(3):

Dong E, Wang M, Shen S, et al., 2016, 3D Printing of Tissue-

Simulating Phantoms as a Traceable Standard for Biomedical

Optical Measurement. Proc. SPIE 9903:9903021-99030213,

Seventh International Symposium on Precision Mechanical

Measurements, 990302.

Zhao Z, Zhou X, Shen S, et al., 2016, 3D Printing Of Tissue-

Simulating Phantoms For Calibration Of Biomedical Optical

Devices. SPIE/COS Photonics Asia, 10024: 10024N1-


Diep P, Pannem S, Sweer J, et al., 2015, Three-dimensional

printed optical phantoms with customized absorption and

scattering properties. Biomed Opt Express, 6(11): 4212–4220.

Marcu L, Boppart S A, Hutchinson M R, et al., 2017,

Biophotonics: The big picture. J Biomed Opt, 23(2): 21103.

Andreu N, Zelmer A, Wiles S, 2011, Noninvasive

biophotonic imaging for studies of infectious disease. FEMS

Microbiol Rev, 35: 360–394.


Maloth K N, Velpula N, Kodangal S, et al., 2016,

Photodynamic therapy a non-invasive treatment modality for

precancerous lesions. J Lasers Med Sci, 7: 30–36. https://doi.


International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation

Protection, 2017, ICNIRP statement on diagnostic devices

using non-ionizing radiation: Existing regulations and

potential health risks. Health Phys, 112(3): 305–321. https://

Pogue B W, Patterson M S, 2006, Review of tissue

simulating phantoms for optical spectroscopy, imaging

and dosimetry. J Biomed Opt, 11(4): 041102. https://doi.


Gao F, Li J, Zhang L, et al., 2010, Simultaneous fluorescence

yield and lifetime tomography from time-resolved

transmittances of small-animal-sized phantom. Appl Opt,

(16): 3163–3172.

Wang L V, 2008, Prospects of photoacoustic tomography. Med

Phys, 35(12): 5758–5767.

Nordstrom R J, 2011, Phantoms as Standards in Optical

Measurements, Proceedings SPIE 7906, Optical Diagnostics

and Sensing XI: Toward Point-of-Care Diagnostics; and

Design and Performance Validation of Phantoms Used in

Conjunction with Optical Measurement of Tissue III. https://

Lamouche G, Kennedy B F, Kennedy K M, et al., 2012,

Review of tissue simulating phantoms with controllable

optical, mechanical and structural properties for use in optical

coherence tomography. Biomed Opt Express, 3(6): 1381–

Bouchard J, Noiseux I, Veilleux I, et al., 2011, The role

of optical tissue phantom in verification and validation of medical imaging devices. Int Workshop Biophotonics,

: 1–3.

Oregon Medical Laser Center (OMLC), 2017, Optical

Phantoms. Available from:

phantom. [Last accessed on 2018 Oct 17].

Vernon M L, Fréchette J, Painchaud Y, et al., 1999, Fabrication

and characterization of a solid polyurethane phantom for

optical imaging through scattering media. Appl Opt, 38(19):


Rang M, Jones A C, Zhou F, et al., 2008, Optical near-field

mapping of plasmonic nanoprisms. Nano Lett, 8(10): 3357–

Bisaillon C É, Dufour M L, Lamouche G, 2011, Artery

phantoms for intravascular optical coherence tomography:

Healthy arteries. Biomed Opt Express, 2(9): 2599–2613.

Lai P, Xu X, Wang L V, 2014, Dependence of optical scattering

from intralipid in gelatin-gel based tissue-mimicking

phantoms on mixing temperature and time. J Biomed Opt,

(3): 35002.

Pleijhuis R, Timmermans A, De Jong J, et al., 2014, Tissue simulating

phantoms for assessing potential near-infrared

fluorescence imaging applications in breast cancer surgery.

J Vis Exp, 91: 51776.

Mehrban N, Teoh G Z, Birchall M A, 2016, 3D bioprinting

for tissue engineering: Stem cells in hydrogels. Int J Bioprint,

(1): 14.

Jang T S, Jung H D, Pan H M, et al., 2018, 3D printing of

hydrogel composite systems: Recent advances in technology

for tissue engineering. Int J Bioprint, 4(1): 126. https://doi.


Li J, Mooney D J, 2016, Designing hydrogels for controlled

drug delivery. Nat Rev Mater, 1: 16071. https://doi.


Zhang X, Xia L Y, Chen X, et al., 2017, Hydrogel-based

phototherapy for fighting cancer and bacterial infection.

Sci China Mater, 60(6): 487–503.


Guo X, Qu J, Zhu C, et al., 2018, Synchronous delivery of

oxygen and photosensitizer for alleviation of hypoxia tumor

microenvironment and dramatically enhanced photodynamic

therapy. Drug Deliv, 25(1): 585–599.


Wilson B C, Patterson M S, 2008, The physics, biophysics

and technology of photodynamic therapy. Phys Med Biol,

(9): R61.

Chmarra M K, Hansen R, Mårvik R, et al., 2013, Multimodal

phantom of liver tissue. PLoS One, 8(5): e64180. https://

Alexei K, Srirang M, Rosalyn S, et al., 2003, Poly(vinyl

alcohol) gels for use as tissue phantoms in photoacoustic

mammography. Phys Med Biol, 48(3): 357. https://doi.


Avtzi S, Zacharopoulos A, Psycharakis S, et al., 2013,

Fabrication and Characterization of a 3-D Non-Homogeneous

Tissue-Like Mouse Phantom for Optical Imaging,

st International Conference “Biophotonics Riga 2013”,

SPIE, 6.

Wang K, Ho C C, Zhang C, et al., 2017, A review on the

D printing of functional structures for medical phantoms

and regenerated tissue and organ applications. Engineering,

: 653–662.

Velasquillo C, Galue E A, Rodriquez L, et al., 2013, Skin 3D

bioprinting. Applications in cosmetology. J Cosmet Dermatol

Sci Appl, 3(1): 5.

Seer P, 2018, Analysis of Patents, Search and Project

Collaboration. Available from:

[Last accessed on 2018 Sep 24].

Jang J, Yi H G, Cho D W, 2016, 3D printed tissue models:

Present and future. ACS Biomater Sci Eng, 2(10): 1722–1731.

Bishop E S, Mostafa S, Pakvasa M, et al., 2017, 3-D bioprinting

technologies in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine:

Current and future trends. Genes Dis, 4(4): 185–195. https://

Sokolov K V, Galvan J, Myakov A V, et al., 2002,

Realistic three-dimensional epithelial tissue phantoms for

biomedical optics, J Biomed Opt, 7(1): 148–156. https://doi.


Lurie K L, Smith G T, Khan S A, et al., 2014, Threedimensional,

distendable bladder phantom for optical

coherence tomography and white light cystoscopy. J Biomed

Opt, 19(3): 36009.

Kim H, Hau N T, Chae Y G, et al., 2016, 3D printing-assisted

fabrication of double-layered optical tissue phantoms for

laser tattoo treatments. Lasers Surg Med, 48(4): 392–399.

Sangha G S, Hale N J, Goergen C J, 2018, Adjustable

photoacoustic tomography probe improves light delivery

and image quality. Photoacoustics, 12: 6–13. https://doi.


Ghassemi P, Wang J, Melchiorri A J, et al., 2015, Rapid

prototyping of biomimetic vascular phantoms for hyperspectral reflectance imaging. J Biomed Opt, 20(12):

Bentz B Z, Costas A, Gaind V, et al., 2017, 3D Printed Optical

Phantoms and Deep Tissue Imaging for in vivo Applications

Including Oral Surgery, Proceeding SPIE 10056, Design and

Quality for Biomedical Technologies X, 1005607. https://doi.


Lv X, Chen H, Liu G, et al., 2018, Design of a portable

phantom device to simulate tissue oxygenation and blood

perfusion. Appl Opt, 57(14): 3938–3946. https://doi.


U.S. Food and Drug Administration, 2018, About FDA.

Available from:

htm. [Last accessed on 2018 Oct 17].

National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2017, About

NIST. Available from: [Last

accessed on 2018 Oct 17].

Fanjul-Vélez F, Arce-Diego J L, 2011, Light Propagation in

Turbid Media: Application to Biological Tissues, Proceedings

of 21st International Conference Radioelektronika 2011.


Teisseire M, Han A, Abuhabsah R, et al., 2010, Ultrasonic

backscatter coefficient quantitative estimates from Chinese

hamster ovary cell pellet biophantoms. J Acoust Soc Am,

(5): 3175–3180.

Brien W D O, Han A, Auger T, 2012, Quantitative Ultrasound

from Single Cells to Biophantoms to Tumors, 2012 Annual

International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in

Medicine and Biology Society. p. 1118–1120. https://doi.


Han A, Abuhabsah R, Miller R J, et al., 2013, The

measurement of ultrasound backscattering from cell pellet

biophantoms and tumors ex vivo. J Acoust Soc Am, 134(1):


Han A, O’Brien W D, 2015, Structure function for highconcentration

biophantoms of polydisperse scatterer sizes.

IEEE Trans Ultrason Ferroelectr Freq Control, 62(2): 303–

Cristea A, Franceschini E, Lin F, et al., 2015, Quantitative

characterization of concentrated cell pellet biophantoms

using statistical models for the ultrasound echo envelope.

Phys Procedia, 70: 1091–1095.


Azizi S, Bayat S, Rajaram A, et al., 2018, 3D Tissue Mimicking

Biophantoms for Ultrasound Imaging: Bioprinting and Image

Analysis, Proceeding SPIE 10576, Medical Imaging 2018:

Image-Guided Procedures, Robotic Interventions, and

Modeling, 105761T.

Wróbel M S, Jędrzejewska-Szczerska M, Galla S, et al.,

, Use of optical skin phantoms for preclinical evaluation

of laser efficiency for skin lesion therapy. J Biomed Opt,

(8): 85003.

Liu Y, Ghassemi P, Depkon A, et al., 2018, Biomimetic

D-printed neurovascular phantoms for near-infrared

fluorescence imaging. Biomed Opt Express, 9(6): 2810–2824.

Wilson B C, Jermyn M, Leblond F, 2018, Challenges and

opportunities in clinical translation of biomedical optical

spectroscopy and imaging. J Biomed Opt, 23(3): 30901.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2019 Marisela Rodriguez-Salvador

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.